Article

Why the companies you email never reply

Most of the companies you email do not reply because they do not know they have the problem you solve, or they know something is wrong but did not know it could be fixed. Your message assumes they already know.

Matteo Merlo · Updated on

Vendorius B2B finds the companies that can buy what you sell, emails them and books the meeting in your calendar. We write about this because it is one of the things we see most often in campaigns that do not work.

Are the companies you email all at the same point?

No, and this is the one thing to understand. The companies that could buy from you know different things. Some have no idea they have the problem you solve. Some know they have a problem, and that is all. Some know it can be fixed but do not know how yet. Some have already decided what kind of solution they want and are choosing who to buy it from. At the top are the few who already know who you are: they are the ones who buy.

The largest group is always the first one, the companies that do not even know they have the problem. If you send everyone the same message, you only speak well to the last group, which is the smallest.

And one fact makes it worse. In Italy, where we run most of our campaigns, there are about 6 million active companies, and about 500,000 of them are listed on Apollo and Clay, the tools almost the whole market builds its lists from: those are the companies everyone already emails. If you write only to them, your message lands next to everyone else's.

The idea is not ours. It comes from an American advertising book from 1966, Breakthrough Advertising by Eugene Schwartz, which splits buyers into five levels of awareness. Matteo explains it to clients and to the people who work with him, because it is how you decide who to write to and what to say.

A five-level pyramid with many figures at the base, among those who do not know what you solve, and only two at the top, among those who buy.
The companies that could buy from you are not all at the same point, and the largest group does not know it has the problem. Source of the levels, Eugene Schwartz, Breakthrough Advertising, 1966.

What happens when you send the right message to the wrong company?

Take a company that lives on referrals and a couple of big clients, and whose owner is sure nothing is wrong. If you write "you need sales meetings", the answer is that clients come in by referral and the business is doing fine. You cannot even ask "do you have fewer clients this year?", because the owner does not see the problem.

Then take the owner who sees revenue going down and referrals drying up, but does not know that cold email, cold calling or LinkedIn exist. Writing "we will book you meetings" does not work here either, for the opposite reason: this owner does not know who you are, what you do, or that email can bring meetings at all.

An owner with a "Revenue declining" card on the left and a list of solutions on the right, with Cold email chosen and the others crossed out.
The owner who only knows something is wrong does not know yet how to fix it. Any direct pitch, including "I'll book you meetings", does not reach them.

What should you write, depending on where the company is?

Where the company isWhat does not workWhat works
Does not know it has the problemany offerstories, events, a long way round; better avoided at first
Only knows it has a problemtalking about the solution or about youtalking about its problem, with something about that company
Knows it can be fixed, not howintroducing yourselfshowing with data and proof why the other routes do not fit and yours does
Has decided what kind of solution it wantsexplaining the problem from scratchthe numbers, and what you do that others do not

The second case is the one people get wrong most often. To a company that only knows something is wrong, you do not write "we will book you meetings". You write about its problem. For example: you look at its financial statements, you see that revenue has dropped, and you send a document that explains, by your own estimate, how it got there.

Who gets the numbers, and which ones?

The companies higher up, the ones that have already decided what kind of solution they want and only need to choose who to buy it from. The closer to the top, the more direct the offer can be. The numbers we bring are those of our own campaigns: across our campaigns, about 5.3% of the companies contacted reply.

Related pages

The numbers on this page. The roughly 6 million active companies in Italy and the roughly 500,000 listed on Apollo and Clay are our own figures, which anyone with an account on those tools can check. The 5.3% is the reply rate across our set of campaigns: companies that reply out of companies contacted. It is not a figure about the market as a whole, and it changes a lot from one sector to another. 1966 is the year Breakthrough Advertising by Eugene Schwartz was first published, which is where the five levels come from: a bibliographic fact, not ours. The two owners are examples from the video.

The full video

Tell us what you sell and to whom. On a call we give you the count of companies that match your criteria, before any proposal.

Book a call →

Read next